Issues with Getting Homeowners Insurance in Florida

Current Issues with Getting Homeowners Insurance for Florida Homes

Issues with Getting Homeowners Insurance in Florida

One of the new challenges for homebuyers is securing homeowners insurance in Florida. It truly is becoming increasingly challenging for many residents. The state’s susceptibility to hurricanes, flooding, and other natural disasters, combined with market instability, has created a perfect storm for homeowners trying to protect their properties. In 2024, these issues have escalated, making it harder and more expensive to get the coverage necessary to safeguard homes in the Sunshine State.

Getting homeowners insurance in Florida is no joke these days. Between the constant threat of hurricanes and rising sea levels, insurance companies are hiking premiums and even pulling out of the state. In 2024, the average Florida homeowner is shelling out more than $11,000 a year for insurance, which is crazy compared to the rest of the country. And it’s not just the storms — inflation and skyrocketing rebuilding costs are also to blame, making it more expensive for insurers to cover damages. Plus, with a bunch of companies leaving the market, there are fewer options out there.

For homeowners, it’s a tough spot to be in, but there are a few things you can do to ease the pain. First, shopping around for insurance is more important than ever, especially with fewer players in the game. You can also look into improving your home’s hurricane resilience (think impact-resistant windows and reinforced roofs) to lower premiums. And if you’re really stuck, there’s always Florida’s Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, a state-run option, though it tends to be more expensive. Bottom line: Stay informed, and don’t be afraid to ask around for better rates.

Why Is It Hard to Get Homeowners Insurance in Florida?

1. Increased Risk from Natural Disasters

Florida’s geography makes it particularly vulnerable to natural disasters, especially hurricanes 🌀 and floods 🌊. The state has experienced several significant hurricanes in recent years, such as Hurricane Ian in 2022, which caused over $60 billion in damages. This has led insurers to either leave the market or increase their premiums dramatically​.

The constant risk of hurricanes, combined with rising sea levels due to climate change, has made it more difficult for insurance companies to offer affordable and comprehensive coverage. Many insurers have raised rates to account for these increased risks, while others have withdrawn from the Florida market altogether.

2. Rising Insurance Premiums

In 2024, Florida homeowners are paying some of the highest insurance premiums in the country. The average annual premium for homeowners insurance is expected to exceed $11,000, significantly higher than the national average​. This sharp rise in costs is due to a variety of factors:

  • Hurricane damage claims: High claim rates after significant hurricanes have forced insurers to hike prices.
  • Rebuilding costs: The cost of materials and labor has surged due to inflation, making it more expensive to rebuild homes after a disaster​.
  • Reinsurance costs: Florida insurers rely on reinsurance (insurance for insurance companies), and the cost of reinsurance has skyrocketed in recent years, further driving up premiums​.

3. Shrinking Pool of Insurers

Many national insurance companies have pulled out of the Florida market entirely, leaving homeowners with fewer choices. In 2023 and 2024, major players like United Property & Casualty Insurance Company either went bankrupt or left the state, further shrinking the already limited market​.

This has led to a reliance on smaller, regional insurance companies that often have less financial stability. The Florida government has taken steps to attract new insurers to the market, but capacity remains an issue. As a result, finding an insurer willing to cover your home has become increasingly difficult.

Key Issues Impacting Homeowners Insurance in Florida

Hurricane Risk and Climate Change

  • Hurricanes are the primary driver of Florida’s high insurance costs, as they can cause catastrophic damage. The increasing frequency and intensity of these storms due to climate change is a concern for insurers, who must anticipate and prepare for the potential devastation.
  • Properties in coastal areas and flood zones are particularly at risk, and homeowners in these regions often face higher premiums or are required to purchase separate flood insurance policies.

Litigation and Fraud

  • Florida has been a hotbed for insurance litigation, particularly with assignment of benefits (AOB) fraud, where homeowners sign over insurance benefits to contractors, leading to inflated claims and legal disputes. While recent reforms have aimed to reduce such fraud, litigation still burdens insurers and contributes to higher premiums​.

Rebuilding Costs and Inflation

  • The cost of rebuilding homes after a disaster has soared due to inflation. The price of construction materials, labor, and fuel has risen sharply, adding pressure on insurers to cover these increased expenses. Homeowners, in turn, are bearing the brunt of these costs through higher premiums.

Visual Overview of Key Issues in Florida Homeowners Insurance

Issue Impact on Insurance Key Factors
🌀 Hurricanes Increases premiums or cancellations High risk of storm damage
🌊 Flood Zones Expensive flood coverage Proximity to coastlines and flood areas
🔥 Litigation Issues Higher premiums and fewer insurers Fraud, legal disputes
🏗️ Rebuilding Costs Drives up premiums Inflation, material, and labor costs

Government Efforts and Relief Measures

In response to these mounting challenges, Florida’s government has introduced several relief measures aimed at curbing the impact on homeowners. Governor Ron DeSantis’ 2024 budget includes a one-year exemption on property insurance taxes for homes valued under $750,000, which could save homeowners approximately 6% on their premiums​. However, while these measures offer some relief, they are temporary and do not fully address the long-term issues plaguing the insurance market.

Additionally, programs like My Safe Florida Home encourage homeowners to make their homes more resistant to hurricane damage, offering financial incentives for adding impact-resistant doors, windows, and metal roofs. These improvements not only enhance home safety but also reduce insurance premiums by mitigating risk.

What Homeowners Can Do

1. Shop Around for the Best Rates

With fewer insurers in the market, it’s more important than ever to shop around and compare rates from multiple providers. While larger national insurers may have pulled out of Florida, smaller regional companies may offer competitive rates and coverage options.

2. Improve Your Home’s Resilience

Making your home more hurricane-resistant can significantly reduce your insurance premiums. Consider installing impact-resistant windows, reinforcing your roof, and adding storm shutters. Many insurers offer discounts for homes that meet stringent safety standards.

3. Explore State-Run Insurance Options

If you’re struggling to find coverage through private insurers, you may be eligible for Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Florida’s state-run insurer of last resort. While Citizens provides coverage for homes that private insurers won’t cover, it’s often more expensive and should be considered as a backup option.

Florida Homeowners Insurance

The Florida homeowners insurance market is facing unprecedented challenges in 2024, driven by rising natural disaster risks, a shrinking pool of insurers, and increasing rebuilding costs. While government relief measures offer some respite, the future of affordable and accessible homeowners insurance in Florida remains uncertain.

For homeowners, the key to navigating this landscape lies in improving home resilience, staying informed about insurance options, and keeping up with the latest legislative changes. By taking proactive steps, Florida residents can protect their homes and mitigate the rising costs of insurance.

Why are homeowners insurance premiums so high in Florida?
High hurricane risks, increasing rebuilding costs due to inflation, and a shrinking pool of insurers have contributed to skyrocketing premiums in Florida.

Can I still get homeowners insurance in high-risk areas like coastal Florida?
Yes, but you may need to seek coverage from smaller regional insurers or state-run options like Citizens Property Insurance.

How can I lower my homeowners insurance premiums in Florida?
Improving your home’s hurricane resistance by installing impact-resistant windows or doors can lower your premiums. You can also shop around for better rates from multiple insurers.

What government programs are available to help with homeowners insurance?
Programs like My Safe Florida Home offer financial incentives for making your home more resilient to hurricanes. Additionally, the state provides temporary tax exemptions for property insurance.


Ready to navigate Florida’s homeowners insurance challenges? Contact our experts today for personalized advice and explore more insights on protecting your home in the Sunshine State.

#FloridaHomeInsurance #HomeownersInsurance #HurricaneInsurance #FloridaRealEstate #InsuranceChallenges

Home-Owners-Insurance-Challengesjpg

Michael Clark

Visit Our Website

More about this AgentsGather Author and Expert: Michael Clark
Michael Clark https://agentsgather.com/profile/michaelclark5/
It's Nice to Share

Comment, Write a Blog Post, Create Groups, Get Seen!

Comments, Opinions and Facts Go Here...👇

No comments yet

Search The Best Real Estate Network