SHOULD YOU ADD AN ADU TO YOUR INVESTMENT PROPERTY: PROS, CONS, AND FINANCING OPTIONS

SHOULD YOU ADD AN ADU TO YOUR INVESTMENT PROPERTY: PROS, CONS, AND FINANCING OPTIONS

An accessory dwelling unit (ADU), often referred to as a “mother-in-law” or “granny flat,” is a secondary living space on the same lot as an existing single-family home. To be considered an ADU, the space must include living, sleeping, eating, cooking, and sanitation facilities, making it a self-sufficient dwelling.

While ADUs have traditionally been used to house family members during times of economic or housing instability, they have recently gained popularity as income-producing assets in the rental market. The potential to increase passive income from existing investment properties can be enticing, but ADUs come with their own set of challenges.

Let’s explore the pros, cons, and common challenges associated with investing in ADUs:

The Pros of Adding an ADU to an Investment Property

There are several advantages to adding an ADU to your investment property, including:

1. Increased Rental Income

ADU investments have become increasingly popular due to their potential for generating rental income. By transforming a single-family home into multiple rentable units, investors can increase cash flow and boost their return on investment.

2. Maximizing Property Use

ADUs allow investors to make the most of their property without purchasing additional land. Various ways to add an ADU include:

Converting basements to meet rental requirements

Turning attached or detached garages into livable spaces

Redesigning a home’s layout to create multiple self-contained areas

Adding a prefabricated ADU on the property

Many ADUs are built with energy-efficient designs, reducing their environmental impact compared to larger housing units. Moreover, with housing affordability declining and average monthly rents exceeding $1,600, ADUs offer investors a way to provide more affordable rental options.

3. Enhanced Property Value

Beyond generating additional income, ADUs tend to increase a property’s resale value. Homes with ADUs often sell at premium prices, especially in densely populated urban areas. This is due to the extra revenue potential an ADU offers future buyers. Studies show that properties with ADUs can sell for up to 35% more than comparable homes without them.

4. Diversifying Tenant Types

ADUs appeal to a broad range of tenants, including singles, students, small families, and young professionals, thanks to their affordability. By diversifying the tenant pool, property owners can reduce the risk of vacancy and maintain a steady income stream.

5. Flexible Living Options

ADUs can also serve as flexible living spaces for extended families, providing privacy while maintaining proximity. This is ideal for multi-generational households who want to live together while maintaining independent living quarters.

The Cons of Adding an ADU to an Investment Property

While ADUs offer numerous benefits, there are also some challenges investors need to consider:

1. Upfront Costs and Financing Challenges

Building an ADU can be costly. The average cost is around $180,000 ($260 per square foot), but this number can vary based on location. In cities like San Francisco or Austin, costs can rise to $300,000. Additionally, investors should factor in property tax increases, permitting fees, and other expenses.

While ADUs can generate long-term income, securing financing for an ADU on a non-owner-occupied property can be challenging. Traditional lenders, such as banks, often have strict requirements and less flexibility, making it difficult to find suitable ADU financing options.

2. Zoning, Regulatory, and Permitting Hurdles

ADU construction comes with complex zoning laws and building codes that differ from city to city. Non-owner-occupied properties often face stricter guidelines and longer approval processes. It’s essential to conduct due diligence and consult local officials about ADU regulations before proceeding with any project.

3. Operational and Management Complexities

Managing two rental units within the same property can be more challenging for landlords. More tenants mean additional responsibilities such as:

Marketing and tenant screening

Maintenance and repairs

Rent collection and tenant communications

Potential conflicts between tenants sharing common spaces

A robust property management plan is necessary to handle these additional complexities effectively.

4. Impact on Neighborhood Relations and Market Demand

Neighbor resistance to ADU construction is not uncommon. Concerns about privacy, noise, traffic, parking, and property values may arise, particularly in single-family neighborhoods. Additionally, not all neighborhoods will have the demand to justify an ADU’s added expense, so investors should carefully assess the local rental market.

Financing Options for an ADU on a Non-Owner-Occupied Property

If you decide that adding an ADU makes sense, choosing the right financing option is crucial. Below are five common financing methods for ADU construction on non-owner-occupied properties:

1. Investment Property Loans

Investment property loans are offered by traditional lenders for rental properties. While they often come with lower interest rates, they have strict requirements, lengthy application processes, and numerous guidelines that may not suit all investors.

2. Cash-Out Refinance

Cash-out refinancing allows you to borrow against the equity in your property to finance ADU construction. This option typically offers lower interest rates and easier qualifications but extends your mortgage term and increases closing costs. If your rental units are vacant for a prolonged period, you may also face the risk of foreclosure.

3. Private Lenders

Private lenders offer short-term business loans with faster approval and more flexible terms than traditional lenders. These loans may come with higher interest rates, but their flexibility and speed can benefit investors, especially when financing unconventional projects like tiny homes or basement conversions. Many private lenders also specialize in construction loans, funding projects in stages as needed.

4. Construction Loans for Investors

These loans are designed for building or renovating rental units. Rather than a lump sum, construction loans pay out in stages throughout the project. Although interest rates are higher, construction loans offer structured payouts, making them a viable option for ADU projects.

5. Joint Ventures or Partnerships

Partnering with other investors through a joint venture can reduce financial risk and increase capital. However, this approach may involve compromises, negotiations, and profit sharing, which could impact your overall return on investment.

Creating Financial Success with ADUs

For real estate investors, adding an ADU to a non-owner-occupied property can be a smart way to diversify income streams, increase property value, and tap into new tenant markets. However, it’s important to thoroughly research local building costs, regulations, and financing options. In some areas, the cost and regulatory barriers may outweigh the benefits.

If you’re considering adding an ADU to your investment property, TN3B Financial can help. CLICK HERE to schedule a FREE consultation today.

Merrill Strachan

Certified Private Money Lender

(800) 701-6120

www.tn3bfinancial.com

You’re just ONE DEAL AWAY!